Only the Gays and the Irish Want to Save St. Brigid's


Wednesday, August 23, 2006, by Joey

2006_8_brig.jpg...Or at least that's what you'd think from reading this Daily News story on the Hibernians—the dudes in charge of the no-gays-allowed St. Patrick's Day parade— who are now campaigning to turn the endangered Avenue B church into the state's Irish American History Museum. A group that has been protested for being anti-gay, willing to create a museum in the "gay-friendly East Village?" The potential for comment is not lost on anyone involved, including the organizer of Queens' St. Patty's Day parage, who said: "Isn't it ironic now that the gays and the [Hibernians] and everyone else are coming together over a planned demolition?"

Will the gays have their way? We could find out tomorrow, when Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Barbara Kapnick is expected to respond to archdiocese lawyers who want to lift an injunction holding up the demolition. And don't expect a change of heart from God's Army, either. Cardinal Egan's spokesman told the DN: "Museums are fine things, but that is not what the archdiocese is in place for." So stick that in your Prada fannypack and sigh at it!
· Hibernians & gays on same page [DailyNews]
· BREAKING: Judge Halts St. Brigid's Demolition [Curbed]
· BREAKING: St. Brigid's Will Not Be Condos [Curbed]


Comments feed for this post Feed icon


Comments (27 extant)

1.

There was a report published by the Brookings Institute a while back that seemed interesting. The report mentioned that of all ethnicities on the planet the one that exhibited the most prevelant homosexual tendencies was the Irish. Something like 35% of all gays were Irish on the planet. The next closest was the Taiwanese at 14%, I think it was. Just amazing how a culture so hell bent on the persecution of gays in America seems to be so very much inclined genetically to be gay back in the motherland. Just interesting.

By McCoy at August 23, 2006 9:16 AM

2.

The Gays The Straights the Bisexual Transexuals are here. They are all here. The Gays, The Straights, the Bisexuals Transexuals are here. They are all here. It's Over. ha ha. It's Over. ha ha

By robertA Jameson at August 23, 2006 9:31 AM

3.

Don't you mean Thai's, not Taiwanese?

By The Abbot at August 23, 2006 9:43 AM

4.

I believe Taiwan is for all practical purposes are racially, culturally, and linguistically Chinese.

By D at August 23, 2006 9:51 AM

5.

D you have no clue what you are talking about. that is completely wrong.

By toaster at August 23, 2006 9:57 AM

6.

Sorry, I'm retarded. I just found out that Taiwanese people are from Taiwan and Thai people are from Thailand. Obviously #1 was referring to the people from Taiwan. Thought they were the same all along. LOL! Silly me.

By The Abbot at August 23, 2006 9:59 AM

7.

I am appalled by your statements. Where is your source? Why do you insist in referring to Chinese as feminine and gay. Fuck you!

By Taiwanese at August 23, 2006 10:00 AM

8.

Chinese, thai, taiwanese, japanese, koreans, they all look the same. They are short, scrawny, pasty, feminine, weird, horrible fashion sense, geeky, and have weird eyes.

hugs and kisses!!!!

By Svetlana at August 23, 2006 10:10 AM

9.

What in god's name has happened to this website lately? These discussions are absurd. I just come here to look at pretty pictures of new developments. Seems others are up to no good.

By Queens Fiest at August 23, 2006 10:23 AM

10.

The archdiocese doesn't care what happens to this building because ITS FALLING DOWN AND IS CONSTRUCTED POORLY.

The idiots preserving this are insane.

By ho-mey at August 23, 2006 10:25 AM

11.

You know what, I´m not gay or Tawainese, but fuck this site. It has turned to garbage, and this is due to the efforts of the editorial staff. Fuck you Lock.

By Mike at August 23, 2006 10:31 AM

12.

But no, seriously, have any of you ever been to Thailand's red light district? There's more gays there than our very own East Village.

I know the difference between Thai's and Taiwanese. I I was afraid you didn't, McCoy. Relax.

By The Real Abbot at August 23, 2006 10:32 AM

13.

I'm just happy the Tai-Thai War has taken attention away from the fact that all Irish are now gay.

By Seamus O'Toole at August 23, 2006 10:37 AM

14.

Blueboy or Jungle Juice?

By Sassy at August 23, 2006 10:44 AM

15.

#7 I Hate to tell you this but not all gays are feminine, in fact most are not. The only reason you have that negative stereotype is because they are the only visible members of the homosexual communtiy. Are all black people gang bangers, all Asians good at math, and all Italians well dressed? No, they are not. Now please start thinking before you speak

And if you would like to learn more about my communtiy and my sexuality and how it affects my life please let me know and I can post my email address so that we may be able to meet in person and share our fears about each others lifestyles (this invitation is open to anyone.)

Kevin

By Kevin at August 23, 2006 10:45 AM

16.

Kevin you stupid gay idiot. I never said ALL gays are feminine. I stated that PEOPLE think asians are gay and feminine. Stop categorizing me with others. Post your stupid email address for all I care.

By Taiwanese at August 23, 2006 10:54 AM

17.

kevin.les2683@yahoo.com

Send me an email, and perhaps we can clear up some of our cultural differences.

Hope to hear from you soon

By Kevin at August 23, 2006 11:16 AM

18.

Kevin, stop acting so self-righteous. You are the one with the problems. I have more important things to do than to contact you with you pathetic differences. I am moving to New Jersey

By Taiwanese at August 23, 2006 11:29 AM

19.

I realize summer camp is out and school has yet to begin, but shouldn't all the teenagers posting drivel on this site be on their My Space or Hot or Not accounts?

By Steen at August 23, 2006 12:20 PM

20.

May not be a bad idea to close this particular thread - it seems like freedom of speech has outlived its usefullness once again.

By Arkady at August 23, 2006 12:49 PM

21.

Svetlana, Once again you make me fall in love with you! Best post ever! XOXO

And, in response to the actual posting on St. Brigid's, what make the Hibernians (a fine, if homophobic organization) think that someone named Barbara Kapnick is going to side with them?

I just hope they don't tear it down to build more luxury condos. Maybe they should turn it into a big dance club. Or a health club/gym. A sex palace. Anything but luxury condos.

By Kamasutra Jones at August 23, 2006 1:26 PM

22.

As a community activist, I am amused by all the hoopla on saving this unattractive building. If it were so important, were where all these people for the past 50 years in preserving it? I was also very active in the 150th anniversary commeration of the Great Famine in 1996-1998 and no one ever so much as mentioned this church as significant.

St. Patrick's Old Cathedral on Prince Street and St. Anthony's on Manhattan Avenue in Greenpoint, to name just two, have similar strutural problems but are in a fundraising effort to repair and preserve the edifice.

No one cared to help St. Brigid's until it was too late.

Now it is a cause celebre for Johnny-come-lately activists and Catholic bashers in general. No one is making a stink that the congregation let the synagogue on Rivington Street collapse and turn that into a development.

As for the Hibs, why did it take them so long to get involved? The only people worthy of respect in this whole imbroglio is the predominately Latino/Latina parishioners of St. Brigid's who do not want to lose their local church

Fact is that the Archdiocese has stated that they would like it to be a nursing home.

So, what is these people's problem? You want to save a crumbling underutilized church instead of making it a nursing home your parents might need someday?

By Downtown Boy at August 23, 2006 3:38 PM

23.

Seriously, who are you crackpots and wackjobs?

Anyway, the church may not be that historically or aesthetically important, but the more places like this are torn down and replaced with the ugly cheap glass/brick/stuccojobs you see going up around the East Village, the more this neighborhood will look like hospital alley or the Upper East Side. And I think that sucks balls.

By daniel at August 23, 2006 4:21 PM

24.

hey taiwanese, the word is "your" not "you." there's a difference. welcome to amerikkka.

By fido at August 24, 2006 1:27 AM

25.

Chinese, thai, taiwanese, japanese, koreans, they all look the same. They are short, scrawny, pasty, feminine, weird, horrible fashion sense, geeky, and have weird eyes.
hugs and kisses!!!!

Svetlana

Russian, Ukrainian, Polish, Croatian, Roumanian, they all look the same. You stupid fucking cunt.

By Spuyten at August 24, 2006 2:16 PM

26.

How many of them who want to save this building (besides the Hibs) actually attend church service regularly ("regularly" meaning every week or every other week and not for special occasions like funerals)?

By mad bomber at August 25, 2006 1:42 AM

27.

22 is right.

No one cared until the Archdiocese (bunch of child-molesters that they are) decided to sell it.

If all you people think its so special, pool your money, go out and take out loans, sell your stuff, and buy the damn thing.

Otherwise, shut the fuck up!

By Mike the Laborer at August 25, 2006 10:33 AM




Back to top


photos in Curbed Photo Pool See more and submit to Curbed Photo Pool

Links
New York City
Gawker
Gothamist
Morning News
The Politicker
DailyCandy
Manhattan User's Guide

Real Estate Listings
Curbed's mega-linklist of NYC real estate brokers and listings search sites

Real Estate Blogs & Media
Brownstoner
Matrix
Property Grunt
The Real Estate
The Real Deal
Inman News
Triple Mint
HotelChatter
The Boxtank
The Cooperator
Habitat Magazine
Slatin Report
NYTimes Real Estate
NYPost Real Estate

Real Estate Resources
ACRIS
Trulia
Property Shark
Zillow
RadCribs
RealtyBaron
PostYourProperty
Street Easy

Architecture & Urbanity
The Gutter
Archinect
Tropolism
Wired New York
eOculus
Architects Newspaper
Arch Week
Arch Record
Regional Plan Assoc
Planetizen
Veritas & Venustas
City Comforts
Daily Dose
BLDGBLOG

Design & Shelter
Metropolis
Apartment Therapy
Unbeige
MoCo Loco
Reluct
Cool Hunting
Treehugger
WorldChanging
Sensory Impact
Funfurde
DesignSponge
GNR8
Land & Living
Hamptons C&G

Community Media
Village Voice
NYPress
Gotham Gazette
The Villager
Downtown Express
Resident
Hell's Kitchen Online
Tribeca Trib
East-Village.com
Volume NYC
L Magazine
Block Magazine
Brooklyn Papers

Big Media
NYTimes
NYPost
NYDailyNews
New York Mag
NYObserver
Newsday
Crain's


About Curbed
In New York City, it comes back to real estate, rent and the neighborhoods we inhabit. More about Curbed...

Archives & Feeds


Full content feed

Search this site



Credits
CURBED NY


Senior Editor
Joey Arak

Brooklyn Editor
Robert Guskind

Contributing Editor
Pete Davies

Roving Photographer
Will Femia

Logo
Khoi Uong


CURBED NETWORK
Editorial Director
Ben Leventhal

Sales
Joshua Albertson

Head of Technology
Eliot Shepard

Publisher/GM
Kyle Crafton

President
Lockhart Steele

Other Curbed Sites
New York
Eater NY
Racked
The Beach (seasonal)

San Francisco
Curbed SF
Eater SF

Los Angeles
Curbed LA
Eater LA


Contact Us
Email Curbed

Copyright © 2008 Curbed